Judge Issues Ruling In Favor Of Limelight Networks Over Akamai Patent Lawsuit

Limelight Lawsuit
On Friday, District Court judge Rya Zobel issued a preliminary ruling in the patent infringement lawsuit that Akamai filed against Limelight Networks. Shares in Limelight rose over $4 after the ruling. While I have not had time to read the entire ruling yet, essentially the court rejected the notion that Akamai could patent the way files were delivered over the Internet as per an article on Light Reading.

The article on Light Reading includes quotes that say, "What happened was Akamai was trying to patent the process, as opposed to its technology," Stimson said. "And the judge said, ‘That’s not a process you can patent."

I have not had a chance to speak to anyone from Limelight Networks or Akamai personally yet and neither of the companies have yet to put out an official statement on the wire about the ruling. IF this is the end of the litigation that would be good for both companies and the industry. While lawsuits are part of all industries, they distract all companies involved and don’t allow them to focus all of their efforts on their core business.

I expect we’ll hear more from Akamai and Limelight Networks with official announcements about the ruling before too long.

Sponsored by

YouTube Does NOT Equal 10% Of All Traffic On The Internet

YouTube Traffic Numbers
Last week, I saw a lot of bloggers and news sites talking about a press release put out by Ellacoya Networks, a communications equipment company, that says YouTube accounts for nearly 10% of all traffic on the Internet. Yet, I didn’t notice any bloggers who questioned the report or the data in it. The idea that any company would put out a report that says "YouTube alone comprises approximately 20% of all HTTP traffic, or nearly 10% of all traffic on the Internet" without data to back up such a claim, is absurd.

Looking at the details they announced it says they "released findings based on usage data of approximately one million broadband subscribers in North America". So how does 1 million subscribers in only North America account for all traffic on the Internet when the Internet is global?

Plus, Ellacoya Networks can’t even take the data it has and present it properly. It says, "Breaking down application types within HTTP, the data reveals that traditional Web page downloads represent 45% of all Web traffic. Streaming video represents 36% and streaming audio 5% of all HTTP traffic." Say what? If is is "streaming video" like you say, then how can it be HTTP based? Which one is it? Streaming or HTTP?

They use the term streaming and download in the same phrase twice in the four paragraph release. "Presently, as a result of streaming audio and video in Web downloads, HTTP is approximately 46% of all traffic on the network." Are you talking progressive downloads or streaming?

And they end the press release with a quote that includes them saying, "The way people use the Internet is changing rapidly – from browsing to real-time streaming. We expect to see new applications over the next year that will accelerate this trend." That may be, but you didn’t report on anything that was "real-time streaming" based.

The news sites and bloggers should be doing a better job of questioning data like this and not just posting highlights of a press release just so they have another blog post for the day.

New HD DVD Features Allows Consumers To Edit And Upload Video

HD DVD Features
As Blu-ray and HD DVD continue to battle it out over which format will dominate the market, last week, HD DVD released its first title that incorporates new user features that involves online video. These new features allows anyone who connects their HD DVD player to the Internet via a broadband connection the ability to download trailers to other movies, change menu styles and download other subtitles.

But the most interesting feature is that it will allow anyone to re-edit the movie, arranging the scenes as they want and then allow them to upload their edited video to a server hosted by the studio, in this case to Warner Brothers, for the movie 300. The other users can download that version of the movie to their HD DVD players and watch the re-edited video. What I’m trying to find out is what the technology is behind this, what compression is being used and how large of a file is the user uploading from their house to the studio. And where is the file saved that is being downloaded? To some sort of drive in the HD DVD player or to the disc itself? I can’t find any technical details on the HD DVD site.

All of this seems like a bit of last ditch effort for HD DVD which clearly is not getting the market penetration over Blu-ray. Yes, from the data I have read, more HD DVD players have been sold than Blu-ray, but it’s all going to come down to what content is available. The content will dictate which format wins. And the announcement by Blockbuster two weeks ago that it would not stock HD DVDs when it expands the high-definition section in its 1,450 stores next month and will only stock Blu-ray, is another bad sign for HD DVD.

I say good, let one of these formats fall by the wayside and lets get some standards when it comes to something in U.S.

Verizon’s FiOS Service Pays Off: Adoption Growing, Service Capable Of 50MB Today

FiOS Review
A few months ago I did a review of my Verizon FiOS Internet service commenting on just how good their 20MB fiber connection is for $45 a month. Since that post, I have gotten a lot of e-mails from users all over the country asking for more info on FiOS. Many can’t yet get FiOS or their service does not yet have the ability to get 20MB (I actually have the ability to get 50MB today if I pay more) but they will before too long. To date, my post about FiOS has been the most widely read post on my blog over any other topic.

Verizon has been getting a lot of play in the media lately and in my eyes, it is well deserved. Last week, Verizon announced they had signed up their 1 millionth FiOS Internet customer and has almost half a million FiOS TV subscribers. I know those numbers sound small in relation to the market, but they are growing very quickly quarter to quarter and right now, their percentages are big. 50% of all their Internet customers are also buying video and they have a 16% market penetration rate for FiOS in areas where it is offered. In addition, nearly 80% if all FiOS customer take Internet, video and phone all as one package. Verizon plans to make the service available to 9 million homes by the end of 2007, and 18 million by the end of 2010.

In addition to the fast Internet service, Verizon also offers TV over the FiOS service is some areas. In NY State, Verizon has to apply to each town to get a franchise license to offer the service. I called my town Mayor last week to ask what the hold up was and was told I that a deal with Verizon for my town should hopefully be done within the next 30 days. I can’t wait.

For me, TV is just as big as the Internet because for the first time, I see Verizon having the opportunity to be able to take the Internet and the TV and combine them into a real compelling experience. Last week, Verizon also announced that it plans to offer HD video on demand over the FiOS service. And doing a little bit of research about the cable box that Verizon uses and I found out that in some cases Verizon is using a Motorola set-top boxes, called the “QIP” series that allows broadband companies the ability to offer IPTV services. In addition, the Verizon DVR allows you to record in HD and add the multi-room functionality that allows you to watch recorded programs on multiple TVs in any room in your house.

There is also some interesting reading on CNET, who posted an article about a Q&A session that the CTO of Verizon did with a room full of reporters at the NXTComm telecom tradeshow two weeks ago. Verizon’s CTO said their goal is "to eventually deliver 100 megabits per second to any device in the home." I believe them, as where I live, they are already halfway to that number.

I will be posting a lot more about Verizon’s FiOS service over the coming months and will do a review of the TV service as soon as I can sign up for it. FiOS is the future and for some, the future is now. I have 20MB today, what can I do with it? Not much yet, as there is not a lot of content on the web taking advantage of this type of connection, but there will be soon as Verizon cuts content deals and starts looking at ways they can become a content distributor along with being a carrier.

FiOS is the real deal. It is the service that the industry has all been talking about wanting for years and it’s finally a reality. Good service, fast, cheap and lots of support. Exactly what any product needs to have in order to get mass market adoption.

Job Opening: Sales Director/Senior Sales Executive, Ortiva Wireless

Fresh off their announcement on Monday of raising $15 million, Ortiva Wireless is looking to hire a Sales Director/Senior Sales Executive for the Eastern United States. This person will be responsible for developing strategic partnerships with other ecosystem participants as well as identify opportunities among Ortiva’s target customers, qualify these
opportunities, present Ortiva solutions and negotiate sales.

If you are interested in the opportunity and would like more details on the position, contact John Rogers who is conducting the search.

If you are looking for a new position, have taken a new job or are a
company that has a job opening, let me know. In many cases I will
highlight it here on the blog – free of charge.

Reuters: Asia To beat Europe In Mobile TV

Mobile TV
Interesting short story on Reuters last week talking about how industry executives are saying that they are seeing a shift to where the market in Asia is going to beat out the European market for the adoption of TV to mobile. Newsworthy to me as I always thought the Asian market already had beaten out the European market in terms of adoption. Of course the article also mentions how the lack of standards and spectrum availability in some markets is also hindering the progress.

Job Opening: Technical Project Manager, Video, NYTimes.com

Now that Nick Ascheim has been promoted to VP of Editorial Products at the NYTimes.com, they are looking for someone to take on the roll of technical project manager for video. This position, based in NYC, will lead the development of video, audio, and multimedia software products for The New York Times’ Web site.

You can see full details of the job description, responsibilities and requirements and apply here.

If you are looking for a new position, have taken a new job or are a company that has a job opening, let me know. In many cases I will highlight it here on the blog – free of charge.